appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Kok Xinghui

Ushar Daniele

David D. Lee

Asia is often painted as restrictive and less liberal than the West, but when it comes to abortion, many Asian societies have legalised the medical procedure.
In much of the region, there is close to no debate about banning abortions, despite the United States now attempting to overturn abortion rights.
From metropolitan societies like Singapore and South Korea, to Muslim-majority countries like Indonesia and Malaysia, abortions are legal – albeit tied to varying conditions.
Dr Subatra Jayaraj, a sexual and reproductive health expert and president of the Reproductive Rights Advocacy Alliance Malaysia, said Malaysian laws were “quite progressive” compared to those in the US, and the debate in the US was “not relevant” to Malaysia’s context.

In Singapore, Shailey Hingorani, head of research and advocacy at women’s rights group Aware, said she had not noticed any immediate impact from the US debate on the city state.
Earlier this month, it emerged in a leaked draft paper that the US Supreme Court had voted to strike down the landmark 1973 Roe v. Wade decision, one that guaranteed federal constitutional protections of abortion rights.
“Roe was egregiously wrong from the start,” wrote Justice Samuel Alito, referring to Jane Roe, the legal pseudonym for Norma McCorvey, who fought for the right to abort her third child in the state of Texas. Abortions were then illegal in Texas except when necessary to save the mother’s life.
After abortion, gay marriage? Fears US court may target other rights
If Roe v. Wade is stuck down or scaled back, abortions could again become illegal in many US states.
Abinaya Mohan, head of campaigning at the Women’s Aid Organisation in Malaysia, called the US debacle a regression of women’s rights to bodily autonomy.
“As a whole, the abstinence-first policy is detrimental and does not take into account the realities of women’s lives,” Abinaya said. “And when paired with strict laws on abortion, we have disastrous consequences for so many in our country.”

Abortions have been legal in Singapore since 1969, making it one of the first countries in Asia to allow the procedure for a number of reasons, from family and financial conditions, to pregnancy via rape or incest. Before that, abortion was only allowed if the mother’s life was in danger. It is “relatively progressive”, Hingorani said.
Sociologist Tan Ern Ser said the procedure was likely legalised to help with population control. Back then, Singapore was trying to reduce the nation’s birth rate, and in the 1970s, it had embarked on a campaign encouraging people to have just two children. In 1966, a Singaporean woman had 4.42 children on average. (The average now is a worryingly low 1.12 children born per woman.)
South Korea made a similar attempt at population control decades ago. Although abortions were illegal from 1953, officials had in the 1960s and 1970s encouraged women to go for the procedure. In addition to propaganda posters that read, “Two is enough”, the government also paid for abortions and sent out “abortion buses” that performed the procedure on the road.
The messaging was so prevalent that Jay Kim, a team leader specialising in women’s health and reproduction issues at Korea Womenlink Centre, said women had no idea that abortions were illegal. That only became clear later when falling birth rates prompted the government to crack down on clinics performing abortions.
It was only in 2019 that South Korea ruled that criminalising abortion was unconstitutional, paving the way for legal abortions starting last year.
South Korea proposes allowing abortion until 14th week of pregnancy
As birth rates fell in Singapore and South Korea, so did the number of abortions. There were just 4,029 abortions in Singapore in 2020, compared to 175,929 from 1970 to 1983 – an average of some 12,000 a year. In South Korea, the The Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs estimates that abortions fell 241,411 in 2008 to just under 50,000 in 2017.
Asked if decades of abortion rights in Singapore had benefited the country, sociologist Tan said the matter was not straightforward. If it contributed to declining birth rates, then it was a bad given current low fertility rates, he said.
He said it was also bad if women had relied on abortion as a form of birth control instead of using contraceptives. But if it led to fewer unwanted children being born, “I think the answer is mixed, depending on one’s attitude towards abortion”.

Accessibility
While abortion is legal, varying rules and differing prices mean it’s not always accessible to all women.
In Malaysia, medical practitioners can make decisions “in good faith” to proceed with a termination of pregnancy up to the second trimester.
But the penal code also states that those who induce an abortion with a woman’s consent can be imprisoned for a term of three years or a fine, or both.
Should the woman be “quick with child”, defined as beyond the fourth month of pregnancy, then both she and her abortion provider can be sentenced up to seven years in jail or fined.
Will Indonesia’s sexual violence bill help stem campus harassment?
Subatra, the sexual and reproductive health expert, said this meant abortions could be carried out if “it involves risk to the life of the pregnant woman or injury to the mental and physical health of the pregnant woman”.
Abinaya from Women’s Aid Organisation said this meant doctors were wary of carrying out abortions, leading to some women being denied the procedure or having to turn to illegal clinics. The consequences can be disastrous, she said.
In February, a 15-year-old Malaysian girl was charged with murdering her own baby. She gave birth at home with help from a friend, who left to inform a clinic about the delivery. When clinic staff arrived, they found the baby bleeding from stab wounds. It later emerged that the teenager had been a rape victim.
“The outcome of the case is extremely upsetting and points to a systemic failure to protect girls and women in Malaysia on so many fronts,” Abinaya said. “The state failed to implement safeguards for survivors of sexual violence in the country – including the right to terminate unwanted pregnancies, as well as education and awareness of this.”
In a less extreme scenario, 33-year-old Anna – who declined to use her real name, outlining the stigma surrounding abortions – terminated a pregnancy five years ago. She had just started work and was unmarried, and was not ready to become a mother. But because her pregnancy did not present a risk to her life, physical health or mental health, Anna had to spend 1,200 ringgit (US$273) on an illegal abortion.


In Singapore, while a woman can have an abortion for any reason up to 24 weeks into her pregnancy, she is made to undergo counselling and only have the procedure 48 hours later.
Aware’s Hingorani said this “may inadvertently imply that seeking abortion is morally wrong, inducing artificial guilt and regret”, while also increasing overall costs by forcing multiple trips to the doctor.
Low-income women also struggled to pay the fees that could range from S$300 to S$3,000 (US$215-US$2,150), depending on how far along the pregnancy is, how much anaesthesia is used and if it is carried out at a public hospital or a private clinic, she said.
“This indicates that abortion is not equally accessible to all individuals in Singapore,” she said.
Hingorani said some women had also reached out to Aware, saying social services “use language that clearly suggests their disavowal of abortion and push adoption as the more morally sound option”.
Will India’s surrogacy ban drive childless couples and poor women underground?
In South Korea, Kim said there were still no clear standards for abortions.
There are clinics that will only perform the procedure before 10 weeks of pregnancy, while others are willing to perform surgery after 20 weeks at a price that is four times higher than the average cost for abortions in the country – which is around 1 million won (US$780).
“There hasn’t been new measures to make it more accessible to women, such as providing medical insurance for operations, providing consultation services or allowing medication abortions,” Kim said.
Stigma surrounding abortion also persists in South Korea. Kim recalled speaking to a woman who had called a clinic and was advised to “save” her baby, while another found anti-abortion posters hanging on the hallways of the clinic she visited.
What worries the experts – even though there is still no chatter in Asia about banning abortions – is that tides of opinion can turn overnight.
Kim said the US’ example “just shows that even our laws have the possibility of going into regression”.
Hingorani added: “They tell us how easily rights can be yanked away, despite being widely accepted for decades as a part of a minimum basket of rights for women.”


‘I wasn’t scared’: young Hong Kong rare cancer survivor who stayed positive

Mistrial declared in Lindsay Clancy child killings case

IVF clinic’s embryo specimen mix-up linked to ‘intentional unlawful conduct’

Holdout juror preventing verdict in Lindsay Clancy’s US child murder trial, lawyer says

Reproductive health

Asia’s ‘progressive’ abortion laws safe, but accessibility still an issue in Singapore, Malaysia, South Korea

South Korean protesters hold placards reading “Abolish punishment for abortion” in 2018. File photo: AFP

People at a Women’s March in Washington, DC. File photo: EPA-EFE

Pro-choice demonstrators in Boston rally outside the State House on May 8, 2022. Photo: AFP 

A US demonstrator holds up a sign at an abortion-rights protest in New York. Photo: Bloomberg

Social egg freezing: Singapore follows South Korea, Thailand, Malaysia in allowing procedure as birth rate stagnates

A tube of eggs is placed in cryogenic storage to be used for in vitro fertilisation (IVF). Photo: Getty Images

Staff at a fertility clinic in Kuala Lumpur demonstrate part of the procedure for freezing eggs. Photo: AFP

A woman pushes her baby in a stroller past the rain vortex at Jewel Changi Airport in Singapore. The island nation’s birth rate is among the lowest in the world. Photo: AFP

A tube of eggs is placed in cryogenic storage to be used for in-vitro fertilisation (IVF). Photo: Getty Images

A bride yawns at a mass wedding ceremony in South Korea in 2018. Women in the country are now opting to marry and have children later in life. Photo: AP

An embryologist prepares eggs for thawing at a fertility clinic. Many Asian nations stipulate that a woman’s eggs can only be fertilised by her legal spouse. Photo: The Washington Post via Getty Images

Is Catholic Philippines ready to decriminalise abortion? Its next president is about to decide

A placard in front of the Minor Basilica of the Black Nazarene in Quiapo, Manila, the Philippines. Photo: Getty Images

Pamparegla, a herbal abortion remedy, is sold beside Quiapo Church in Manila. Photo: Geela Garcia

Church-goers pass by sidewalk vendors selling abortion kits beside Quiapo church in the Philippines. Photo: Geela Garcia

Philippine presidential candidate Ferdinand ‘Bongbong’ Marcos Jnr. Photo: Reuters

An empty bed inside the delivery room of Dr. Jose Fabella Hospital, the largest maternity hospital in the country. Some 2,600 women in the Philippines die daily because of complications in pregnancy and childbirth. Photo: Geela Garcia

Philippine Vice-President Leni Robredo. Photo: AFP

Churchgoers praying at the Baclaran Church in Manila. Photo: AFP

Access to safe abortion still a struggle in Asia

Abortion-rights protesters rally in US cities after Supreme Court leak

A protester holds a sign with pictures of Supreme Court justices outside the US Supreme Court in Washington. Photo: AP

A demonstrator with a hanger-shaped sign in New York City. Photo: Bloomberg 

Demonstrators in Los Angeles, California. Photo: Bloomberg

China’s family planning agency says it will ‘intervene’ in abortions for unmarried women, teens

China’s family planning agency will introduce public health programmes to encourage people to have more children. Photo: AFP

This Week in Asia

Health & Environment

People

News

Asia

Southeast Asia

Lifestyle

Health

World

United States & Canada

While Roe v Wade is at risk of being rolled back in the US, no such debates have roiled Asia, although a stigma persists in some places
Women from vulnerable communities and victims of sexual assault still face struggles accessing abortion, as activists warn tides of opinion can turn overnight


While the landmark decision is at risk of being rolled back in the US, no such debates have roiled Asia, although a stigma persists in some places.
