appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Su-Lin Tan

The reimposition of anti-dumping duty on canned pineapples from the Philippines has become a sticking point in Australia’s strategic trade partnership with Manila, highlighting some of the hurdles that could pose a threat to deeper Southeast Asian ties envisioned by Canberra.
In 2021, Australia lifted a 15-year punitive measure against consumer canned pineapples, providing relief to Filipino producers battered by the pandemic.
But the tariffs of between 5.9 and 22.9 per cent were reapplied a year later following an appeal from Golden Circle, Australia’s only producer of canned pineapples. Another separate measure against larger quantities of pineapples used in food services was removed and remained so.
Australian authorities defended the decision saying cheaper Filipino pineapples would continue to “injure” the country’s existing pineapple canning industry, forcing exporters to pay the levies until 2027.
The Philippines is the world’s second-largest exporter of the spiky fruit, according to the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations.
The case posed a test to the two nations that upgraded their bilateral ties to a strategic partnership last year and committed to eliminate “unnecessary barriers” in trade including anti-dumping duties.
This quiet conflict also shows that as Canberra trades with its Southeast Asian neighbours – which is set to rise under a new economic strategy announced this year – the complexities of commerce between niche producers like Australia and low-cost ones in Asia in certain areas like food would continue to surface, experts say.
“There are always going to be some trade issues that emerge between friends and partners, and this is where the international rule-based trading system is really beneficial. It provides balance and predictability,” Nathan Gray, senior fellow at the Institute for International Trade in Adelaide, said.
“The challenge when we think of increasing trade is that it’s not the countries engaging in trade, but the companies within the countries that undertake the participation in trade.”
Golden Circle, a local producer in Queensland which was no longer Australian-owned after being acquired by American multinational Kraft Heinz, first kicked off the anti-dumping case against Filipino pineapples in 2006 claiming the canned fruit was “dumped” or sold at an unfairly low price in Australia.
Also arguing against the claim alongside Filipino manufacturers like Del Monte then was H.J. Heinz Company Australia before it merged with Kraft in 2015. Heinz itself was importing cheaper Filipino canned pineapples into Australia.

For 15 years, Golden Circle successfully maintained that cheaper canned pineapple from the Philippines and other places such as Thailand, Indonesia and China could lead to its consumers switching loyalty until 2021, when the Australian anti-dumping commission said the company operated in its own premium market and was not threatened by low-priced products from these countries.
“Despite the prices of imported goods from the subject countries and other countries being lower than the Australian industry, this does not appear to have impacted the price Golden Circle achieves,” a commission report said.
But in the ensuing appeal, the Australian review panel reversed that ruling saying instead it did not operate in its own “premium” market segment and was therefore not immune to potentially “injurious” competition from cheaper imports.
Golden Circle’s pineapples have long been popular as a key ingredient for Australian-styled burgers and pizzas.
Leading Filipino producer Dole wrote to the panel that the contradictions in these findings or “straw man claims” undermined the integrity of the Australian dumping commission’s “conversion to support for the assertions of the Australian industry”.
Newly elected industry minister Ed Husic at the time of the appeal signed off on the reimposition of the duties.
The Philippine government also voiced its disappointment, saying the country could not be solely responsible for hurting the Australian industry represented by Golden Circle, as there were other low-cost pineapples in the Australian market including those from Indonesia.
Moreover, Golden Circle had been retreating from canned pineapple production due a low supply of local fresh pineapples, it added.
Golden Circle has been using non-Australian pineapples like those from Indonesia in its cans.
“The Philippines urges Australia to, once and for all, terminate the imposition of this 16-year anti-dumping measure on consumer pineapples from the Philippines,” the government said in a letter.
Manila has reiterated its requests in subsequent bilateral discussions. Most other Filipino products face few barriers into Australia, although there was domestic opposition to Filipino bananas previously.
A spokeswoman from Australia’s foreign affairs and trade department said Australian officials have continued to work constructively with their Philippine counterparts regarding trade remedies matters.
“Australia’s independent Anti-Dumping Commission treats all investigations and review processes in a transparent, independent, evidence-based and impartial manner, including in relation to pineapples,” she said.
Deepening economic ties with the Philippines is central to Australia’s latest Southeast Asia Economic Strategy to 2040.

The dark ‘grey’ side of anti-dumping cases
The purpose of Australia’s anti-dumping measures was not to raise prices of imports to solely protect producers like Golden Circle but to make sure foreign competitors did not have an unfair advantage as a result of government subsidies or other incentives that lower the normal cost of production at the expense of a domestic industry in Australia, like pineapple cannery, Gray said.
Golden Circle, which opened in 1947, said the canned pineapple from the Philippines as well as Thailand were at such low prices that made it difficult for it to raise rates in response to increases in production costs.
But this is the dark – or grey – side of anti-dumping laws, Moulis Legal senior lawyer Charles Zhan said in an analysis.
There have been times “Australia’s anti-dumping system has been adjusted and trade restrictive methods were employed, as substitute “weapons” against the effects of trade liberalisation”, Zhan said.
As more tariffs were eliminated through free-trade agreements, the tougher the anti-dumping responses by Australia, he said.
In other words, a free-trade agreement could seem like a paradox, where a promising trade deal could eventually lead to complaints by Australian industries especially against exporters from a country that has seemingly lower costs.
These differences in economic systems and in market regulation could provide fodder for unpleasant trade conflicts, Zhan added.
Indonesia’s win against Australian anti-dumping measures placed on its A4 paper at the World Trade Organization in late 2019 was such a case.
The WTO ruled Australia disregarded the actual and legitimate costs of pulp incurred by Indonesian producers and instead used other surrogate costs to justify the measures.
This method has also been employed against various trading partners like China.
However, Australia honoured the findings of its mistake in the Indonesian case and lifted the A4 anti-dumping measures.
“Australia has a strong reputation as an honest broker in these fora, and has regularly sought to mediate disputes. This is where the balance lies in any trading relationship,” Gray said.
Australian economist John Quiggin told This Week in Asia that he was cynical about the effectiveness of anti-dumping rules as they could form “an easy way” of helping businesses get ahead in low-cost import competition.
He said it might be time to “get rid of anti-dumping measures for selected trading partners that Australia was trying to cultivate”.
As trading partners and their producers fight it out, the ultimate victims, however, were consumers, Australia’s Productivity Commission said in a review of the practice in 2009.
It is consumers who pay the price for any anti-dumping measures, and “lead to less efficient resource use across the economy”, it said.
Meanwhile, there is some reprieve for consumers as cheaper Dole canned pineapples have found their way onto the shelves of Australian supermarkets, though it is the only Filipino brand to feature.


Cathay Pacific’s journey from single post-war plane to aviation powerhouse – SCMP archive

Xi–Trump body language, Thailand’s tourist backlash: 5 weekend reads you missed

Australia just changed its visa rules. So what about its bespoke Hong Kong pathway?

How Asia-Pacific property markets are drawing fresh capital despite US rate uncertainty

Australia

Anti-dumping duty on Philippine canned pineapples: a thorn in Australia-Manila strategic ties?

Canned pineapples from the Philippines face stiff barriers into Australia. Photo: Shutterstock

Golden Circle’s pineapples have long been popular as a key ingredient for Australian-styled burgers and pizzas. Photo: Facebook/GoldenCircle

A pineapple farm in Queensland, Australia. Photo: AP

Prefab paradise? How China-made homes could solve Australia’s housing crisis

Sydney. Australia’s housing shortage has rocketed to the top of the national agenda. Photo: Xinhua

Blocks of flats in the Meadowbank suburb of Sydney. Australia is grappling with a housing affordability crisis. Photo: Bloomberg

A container ship is unloaded at Port Botany in Sydney. Chinese goods made up roughly 70 per cent of Australia’s prefab imports last year. Photo: EPA-EFE

Pedestrians pass residential buildings under construction in Brisbane. Research has shown that foreign-buyer demand provides a business case for new housing development. Photo: Bloomberg

Bibo Build specialises in affordable modular building solutions, capitalising on Australia’s burgeoning market for prefab housing. Photo: Bibo Build/Handout

The interior of a Bibo Build modular home, built using prefab methods. Photo: Bibo Build/Handout

Will Australia’s new multiculturalism road map help boost migrants’ ‘sense of belonging’?

Lanterns hang from above as crowds flock to Dixon Street Mall as part of Lunar New Year celebrations in Chinatown, Sydney, Australia, in January 2022. Photo: Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

A traveller pushes a luggage cart outside Sydney Airport in Australia in November 2021. Photo: Bloomberg

The Lakemba Mosque in the southwestern suburb of Lakemba in Sydney, Australia. A new report has suggested various steps to recognise and preserve the cultural heritage of migrants in Australia. Photo: EPA-EFE

Is Washington orchestrating Manila’s new security pacts as a bulwark against Beijing?

President Joe Biden, center, Philippine President Ferdinand Marcos Jr., left, and Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida pose before a trilateral meeting in the White House in Washington on April 11. Photo: AP

Philippine military chief Gen. Romeo Brawner Jnr, left, shakes hands with Japan Self-Defense Force Chief of Staff General Yoshihide Yoshida on July 8. Photo: AP

Chinese coastguard personnel block Philippine navy boats during a confrontation at the Second Thomas Shoal in the South China Sea on June 17. Photo: Armed Forces of the Philippines

A detachment of Philippine marines sailed to Vietnam-controlled Song Tu Tay island in the South China Sea for a “friendship exchange” of activities including tug of war and football with on July 10. Photo: Philippine Navy

US soldiers seen at the Balikatan joint military drill between US and Philippine troops, in Palawan, the Philippines on May 1. Photo: Jeoffrey Maitem 

This Week in Asia

Economics

News

Asia

Australasia

Southeast Asia

Canberra’s tougher market regulation could provide fodder for trade conflicts as it expands economic ties with Southeast Asian partners


Canberra’s tougher market regulation could provide fodder for trade conflicts as it expands economic ties with Southeast Asian partners.


Anti-dumping duty on Philippine canned pineapples: a thorn in Australia-Manila strategic ties?

.css-1mniedq{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;}Canberra’s tougher market regulation could provide fodder for trade conflicts as it expands economic ties with Southeast Asian partners

Canberra’s tougher market regulation could provide fodder for trade conflicts as it expands economic ties with Southeast Asian partners