appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Brian Wong

A former Hong Kong opposition lawmaker has been cleared of obstructing his political rivals during a chaotic Legislative Council meeting in the lead-up to the 2019 anti-government protests.
West Kowloon Court on Thursday found insufficient evidence to show Lam Cheuk-ting interfered with Legco proceedings over a contentious extradition bill.
The defendant might also have positioned himself at the centre of clashes between the two rival camps in order to understand the situation and express concern for the health of a veteran lawmaker, who was appointed to preside over the meeting on May 11, 2019.
Lam, 48, thanked the presiding magistrate for acquitting him and waved to supporters in the public gallery after the verdict.
The Democratic Party ex-lawmaker is currently serving a combined jail sentence of nearly 10 years in three unrelated cases, including a high-profile national security trial.
He has denied two counts of “assaulting, obstructing or molesting” a member within the precincts of the Legco chamber for allegedly interfering with his then-colleagues Holden Chow Ho-ding and Ben Chan Han-pan, both affiliated with the Democratic Alliance for the Betterment and Progress of Hong Kong.
The May 11 meeting commenced in chaotic fashion after the opposition repeatedly delayed a procedure to elect a chairman overseeing proceedings to scrutinise the extradition bill.
The bill would have enabled the transfer of fugitives from Hong Kong to mainland China, Taiwan and other jurisdictions with which the city previously lacked an extradition agreement, but it was scrapped later that year after triggering citywide unrest.
Video footage showed Chow and Chan forming a cordon with other pro-establishment lawmakers to escort Abraham Razack, who was appointed to preside over the meeting, into a conference room where a separate meeting, hosted by the opposition camp’s James To Kun-sun, was in progress.
Gary Fan Kwok-wai and Eddie Chu Hoi-dick, both in the opposition camp, attempted to climb over their rivals and grab a microphone held by Razack.
Lam held onto Razack’s arm and spoke to him as the latter tried unsuccessfully to allow a chairman to be elected.
In the trial, Chow claimed he had witnessed Lam using whatever means possible to stall the meeting, such as by harassing Razack and trying to grab his microphone.
Chan also contended the defendant kept speaking to Razack with no genuine intention to take part in the discussion.
But the 80-year-old Razack testified in the defence’s favour, saying Lam did not actively intervene with proceedings and that the accused had never used force when he grabbed his arm and asked whether he felt he could carry on.

Lam said he acknowledged Razack as having authority over the May 11 meeting and made it clear to him beforehand that he would not take radical action that day, knowing that his pro-establishment colleague had just undergone heart surgery.
He also claimed that he was concerned about Razack’s condition and tried to convince him to postpone the meeting when he approached the veteran lawmaker and held his arm during the chaos.
In his verdict, Acting Principal Magistrate Andy Cheng Lim-chi found that the video evidence showed that Lam and Razack’s testimonies were plausible, rather than supporting Chow and Chan’s allegations.
While finding that Lam did not want the meeting to proceed smoothly, Cheng said he was unsure if the defendant had intended to impede the election procedure with his physical conduct.
But the magistrate rejected Lam’s request to have prosecutors bear his legal costs of the trial, saying the former lawmaker had brought suspicion upon himself.


Hong Kong teacher jailed for 3 years for molesting pupil during free tutoring

Hong Kong’s IOMed poised to play key role in resolving Greater Bay Area disputes

Hong Kong model Abby Choi’s former relatives admit body disposal, deny murder

Hong Kong authorities won’t appeal court halt to 12,000-flat project on golf course

Hong Kong courts

Ex-Hong Kong lawmaker cleared of obstructing rivals in chaotic 2019 Legco meeting

Lam Cheuk-ting in the Legislative Council building in November 2020. Photo: May Tse

A police officer outside West Kowloon Court. Photo: Karma Lo

Hong Kong court restores jail terms for 4 in HK$51 million Convoy fraud case

The top court handed the ICAC the final victory in its eight-year fight. Photo: Warton Li

Ex-Convoy executive director Mak Kwong-yiu in 2010. Photo: May Tse

Gransing Securities general manager Lee Yick-ming appears at the Eastern Magistrates’ Court in Sai Wan Ho in July 2019. Photo: Jonathan Wong

Ex-Hong Kong policeman accessing confidential info sentenced to community service

The Eastern Court building in Sai Wan Ho. Photo: Nora Tam

The defendant spent nearly a month at Tuen Mun’s Castle Peak Hospital for psychiatric treatment, after which he was barred from carrying firearms. Photo: K. Y. Cheng

News

Hong Kong

Law and Crime

Politics

Court finds insufficient evidence to show Lam Cheuk-ting interfered with Legco proceedings over contentious extradition bill


Court finds insufficient evidence to show Lam Cheuk-ting interfered with Legco proceedings over contentious extradition bill.


Ex-Hong Kong lawmaker cleared of obstructing rivals in chaotic 2019 Legco meeting

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}Court finds insufficient evidence to show Lam Cheuk-ting interfered with Legco proceedings over contentious extradition bill

Court finds insufficient evidence to show Lam Cheuk-ting interfered with Legco proceedings over contentious extradition bill