appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Zoe Low

Hong Kong’s privacy watchdog has made its first arrest under a new law criminalising doxxing, detaining a 31-year-old man in West Kowloon.
The Chinese national was arrested on Monday after the Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data received a report by the alleged victim accusing the suspect of posting their personal details to an online platform, said Lo Dik-fan, of the watchdog’s criminal investigation division.
“This is the first action we have taken since doxxing was criminalised,” said Lo, who serves as acting senior personal data officer. “The case is related to a monetary dispute between the suspect and the victim.”
Authorities also confiscated a mobile phone in connection to the case.
Anti-doxxing bill gets nod in Hong Kong but manpower concerns linger
Legal amendments making the malicious disclosure of personal information illegal took effect in October after being approved by the city’s legislature the month before. Under the new laws, the privacy commissioner can carry out criminal investigations and initiate prosecutions for doxxing.
In the first of the law’s two tiers, the unauthorised disclosure of a victim’s personal data – either with the intent to cause them “specified harm”, or with reckless disregard for the possibility of harm – is punishable by up to two years in jail and a fine of HK$100,000 (US$12,820).
Under the second tier, reserved for cases where such harm actually comes to pass, those penalties increase to a maximum of five years in jail and a HK$1 million fine.
Monday’s suspect was arrested under the offence’s first tier.
The legal amendments also empowered the privacy watchdog to order internet service providers to take down offending content, regardless of whether the disclosure was made in Hong Kong or overseas.
Anyone defying such a request without reasonable justification can be jailed for up to two years and fined as much as HK$50,000 for a first offence. They are also liable to an additional fine of HK$1,000 a day until the material is removed.


As Monday’s case was still under investigation, authorities declined to reveal which online platform was involved or whether any takedown order had been issued.
Lo also declined to say whether the offending content was still online, but nonetheless warned residents against spreading it in the event they had received it.
“If residents see any such information online, I strongly suggest they do not try and share it, as they could be breaking the law as well,” Lo said.
Before the law was amended to specifically criminalise doxxing, the privacy commissioner had been responsible for referring suspected cases to police, who pursued them as various other offences.
‘Hold internet service providers liable for not removing leaked data’: judge
The watchdog said it had referred more than 1,400 cases to the police in the wake of the 2019 anti-government protests, which saw many officials, police officers, journalists and protesters’ personal information maliciously circulated on social media.
A total of 17 people were subsequently arrested, two of whom have since been convicted.
The first was a part-time waitress who managed a doxxing chat room, and who was jailed for three years on charges of conspiracy to incite others to commit arson and conspiracy to do any act with a seditious intention.
The second case involved an Immigration Department clerical assistant who was jailed for nearly four years for misconduct in public office after she used her position to dox 215 individuals.
Hong Kong’s proposed anti-doxxing law far too broad and vague, critics argue
The legal amendments outlawing doxxing, said to be some of the toughest in the world, were widely seen as a move by the government to curb the increasingly widespread behaviour in the aftermath of the 2019 protests.
By last year, doxxing complaints had fallen 76 per cent, the privacy watchdog has said.
Critics of the law have said its reach is too wide, and the Asia Internet Coalition, which represents firms such as Google, Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn, previously warned the broad wording of the amendment was a potential barrier to trade and would discourage the companies from investing or offering their services in Hong Kong.


Hong Kong privacy watchdog arrests boxer for allegedly doxxing opponent

Over 8,200 detained as China launches year-long crackdown on organised crime

Man arrested over doxxing 2 former associates in failed restaurant business

China bans 11 online activities under tighter rules to curb rumours, cyberbullies

Doxxing and cyberbullying

Hong Kong’s privacy watchdog makes first arrest under new anti-doxxing law

Hong Kong authorities have made their first arrest under a new law criminalising doxxing. Photo: Shutterstock

Officers working with Hong Kong privacy watchdog won’t always need warrant to search phones or computers under doxxing law

Officers will be able to stop, search and arrest a person without a warrant, if the person was reasonably suspected to have committed certain offences. Photo: Shutterstock

Ada Chung Lai-ling, Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data (PCPD) responds on the recent controversial privacy policy change by instant messaging app WhatsApp, at PCPD office in Wan Chai. 13JAN21 SCMP / Nora Tam

Hong Kong authorities agree to lower threshold for prosecution under new anti-doxxing law after lawmakers voice concerns

The government has tweaked its proposed anti-doxxing amendments to address concerns raised by pro-establishment lawmakers. Photo: Nora Tam

Lawmaker Holden Chow Ho-ding attends a Legislative Council meeting at the Legislative Council Chamber in Tamar. 24MAY18 SCMP / Dickson Lee

Legislator Priscilla Leung Mei-fun speaks to the press after meeting with meeting Hong Kong Chief Executive Carrie Lam Cheng Yuet-ngor at the Central Government Office in Tamar. 18SEP19 SCMP/ Winson Wong

Doxxing cases, mostly targeting police officers and their families, plunge 76 per cent after Hong Kong protests die down

Out of more than 5,400 cases in the past two years, 38 per cent involved police officers and their family members. Photo: Shutterstock

Anti-riot police on guard in Central as anti-government protesters organise a lunchtime rally to commemorate 7.21 Yuen Long mob attack. 21FEB20 SCMP/ Xiaomei Chen

Hong Kong’s proposed anti-doxxing law far too broad and vague, critics argue

The government says the law is not meant to target online platform service providers, but the bill exposes local staff of global tech giants to criminal liability. Photo: Shutterstock

View of the Legislative Council Complex in Tamar. 28JUL20 SCMP / Nora Tam

Chung Kim-wah, deputy chief executive officer of the Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute (PORI), addresses the media at Hong Kong Public Opinion Research Institute. 10JUL20 SCMP/ Jonathan Wong

News

Hong Kong

Law and Crime


The Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data says the doxxing was related to a monetary dispute between the suspect and the alleged victim
Legal amendments specifically criminalising doxxing took effect in October, and empowered the watchdog to carry out investigations and initiate prosecutions



The Office of the Privacy Commissioner for Personal Data says the doxxing was related to a monetary dispute between the suspect and the alleged victim.


Crime

Crime in Hong Kong

Privacy