appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Elizabeth Cheung

A new law allowing patients in Hong Kong to reject life-sustaining treatments when they are terminally ill will take effect on Friday.
The South China Morning Post looks into how the law will affect patients and healthcare professionals.
1. What is the new law about?
The Advance Decision on Life-sustaining Treatment Ordinance will come into effect on July 31, following its passage by the Legislative Council in November 2024.
The law gives patients the power to reject certain life-sustaining treatments when they are terminally ill and mentally incapable of making decisions.
It also provides legal protection to healthcare professionals and rescuers who honour these medical directives.
2. What is an advance medical directive and DNACPR order?
Both documents are key instruments in end-of-life care, and have been in place in public hospitals since 2010 under common law.
An advance medical directive allows a patient to make instructions in advance on what life-sustaining treatments – such as CPR, blood transfusion, artificial nutrition and hydration – they do not wish to receive when their health deteriorates.
The ordinance specifies three conditions that could trigger the directive to come into effect.
It applies when the patient is terminally ill after an advanced and irreversible medical condition and is expected to live for days, weeks or months.
It also applies when the patient is in a persistent vegetative state or an irreversible coma.
A third situation is when the patient has other end-stage, irreversible and life-limiting conditions, such as end-stage renal failure or dementia.
However, accidents such as car crashes and other acute illnesses do not fall within the criteria for triggering the directive, according to Dr Doris Tse Man-wah, chairwoman of the Hospital Authority’s clinical ethics committee.
A do-not-attempt cardiopulmonary resuscitation (DNACPR) order specifically covers the refusal of CPR for patients who meet the three specified conditions and suffer cardiopulmonary arrest.
The order aims to give clear instructions to rescuers in non-hospital settings when healthcare professionals are not present.
An advance medical directive can be made in paper form and stored electronically on the city’s eHealth platform. The government also plans to allow people to sign the directive directly on the electronic platform at a later stage.

3. Who can draft a directive and DNACPR order?
A mentally capable adult can make the directive in writing on government-recommended model forms to make sure instructions are clearly presented and comply with legal requirements.
The maker of the directive must sign it in the presence of at least two witnesses, one of whom must be a registered doctor.
A DNACPR order can also be made for people who have specified that no CPR should be given as their death approaches. In this case, the order must be signed by two doctors, one of whom must be a specialist.
Adults who are mentally incapable and children cannot make advance medical directives.
However, doctors may issue a DNACPR order for such patients if they and the patient’s family members agree that attempting CPR would not be in the patient’s best interests.
For a child or a mentally incapable adult, the DNACPR order must be signed by two doctors, including a specialist. It also requires a responsible adult, such as a family member, neighbour, or close friend, to agree with the decision and co-sign.
A DNACPR order must be issued in a statutory form and is valid for a maximum of one year. An advance medical directive does not have an expiry date unless it is amended or revoked by the maker.
4. What if family members do not agree?
Patients can revoke their advance directive when they are mentally capable. Other people, such as healthcare professionals, family members, cohabitants or friends, cannot revoke the order.
“We hope that following discussions on advance care planning, patients can clearly express their wishes and family members will also understand,” Tse said.
She said that even if a patient’s decision in the directive might not be in their best interests, instructions made in a valid directive should be followed.
5. Can patients revoke the directive or the order?
Mentally capable patients can revoke the directive at any time. They may destroy the paper document, revoke it in writing, sign the revocation section in the directive, cross out the relevant content and sign on each page or verbally revoke the directive in the presence of an adult witness.
“It is OK to change your mind, but patients should let healthcare professionals know as early as possible,” Tse said.
“If you want to revoke the directives, better destroy everything … or else you cannot rule out that someone might use fragmented documents [as your directive].”
6. Are healthcare professionals liable for non-compliance?
The legislation will protect healthcare professionals from legal liabilities if they comply with a valid directive. Tse said they would also be held liable if they intentionally ignored the directive.
“If you know that a patient has a valid directive and still proceed to perform CPR, you would bear legal responsibility,” she said.
The Fire Services Department, which operates the city’s emergency ambulance service, said that if paramedics could not verify the documents on-site, they would carry out life-saving measures based on the “if in doubt, rescue first” principle.
According to the ordinance, a person who wilfully obstructs a healthcare worker in following another person’s advance directive is liable to a fine of HK$50,000 (US$6,375) and imprisonment for six months.


Hong Kong’s fight against cancer must begin with early screening

Hong Kong minister vows to give public account of Queen Mary Hospital lift saga

Minister rejects claims mainland Chinese nurses are favoured over local candidates

US regulators back multi-cancer blood test – but Hong Kong doctors remain cautious

Hong Kong healthcare and hospitals

How does Hong Kong’s new end-of-life law affect patients and medical staff?

The Advance Decision on Life-sustaining Treatment Ordinance will come into effect on July 31. Photo: Getty Images

A standardised, highly visible document bag used to store a DNACPR order. Photo: Sun Yeung

A video demonstrates how healthcare staff will adopt protocols under a DNACPR order. Photo: Sun Yeung

‘No time to be a detective’: medics warn of split-second calls under new end-of-life law

The Hospital Authority's Doris Tse says ambulance workers have clear guidelines on how to handle emergencies under the new law. Photo: Dickson Lee

Tim Pang of the Society for Community Organization says low-income families may struggle to afford advance directives outside public hospital settings. Photo: Karma Lo

End-of-life directives to go on eHealth as new law takes effect in Hong Kong

The Hospital Authority's Doris Tse says the new ordinance provides clearer legal protection for both patients and healthcare professionals. Photo: Elizabeth Cheung

The Hospital Authority offers yellow bags to patients to store documents related to advance care planning. Photo: Elizabeth Cheung

Paramedics to follow ‘rescue first’ rule if in doubt under new end-of-life law

Queen Elizabeth Hospital. Hongkongers will be able to upload orders specifying which life-sustaining treatments they do not wish to receive when terminally ill. Photo: Edmond So

Fire Services Department’s Gary Tong displays the yellow pouch issued by the Hospital Authority. Photo: Sun Yeung

News

Hong Kong

Health & Environment

The SCMP explores family rights under the law and what happens to healthcare professionals who fail to comply with end-of-life directives


The SCMP explores family rights under the law and what happens to healthcare professionals who fail to comply with end-of-life directives.


Hospital Authority

Medicine

Explainers

How does Hong Kong’s new end-of-life law affect patients and medical staff?

.css-1c6uqr6{color:inherit;font-weight:inherit;font-size:inherit;font-family:inherit;line-height:inherit;overflow-wrap:break-word;}The SCMP explores family rights under the law and what happens to healthcare professionals who fail to comply with end-of-life directives

1. What is the new law about?

The SCMP explores family rights under the law and what happens to healthcare professionals who fail to comply with end-of-life directives