appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Alice Wu

Hong Kong Chief Executive John Lee Ka-chiu said in his most recent policy address that he has “faith in you, the people of Hong Kong”. Call me negative, but I don’t think he does.
This is evident in the fact that no opposition or centrist candidates received sufficient nominations to run in the upcoming district council elections, for which the nomination period ended last Monday. Even Michael Tien Puk-sun’s Roundtable group had a hard time securing enough. Tien’s group had hoped to field five candidates in the direct election, but only one received enough endorsements.
Maybe Lee just doesn’t have faith in politicians? To his credit, not many do – and that appears to be the case across the globe.
But the problem is that Lee is also a politician. He has political power as the city’s chief executive, so it has to be more than that. Is it that Lee is suffering from a crisis of faith in the very system he has been instrumental in putting in place?
National security laws are already in place, with more to come; Lee promised to complete the legislative exercise for enacting national security laws, as stipulated by Article 23 of the Basic Law, by next year. After stripping any real power from the district councils, why is there not enough faith in a revamped electoral system that has more than enough safeguards against non-patriotic forces?

Lee said himself that the law on safeguarding national security in Hong Kong had addressed the “near-vacuum of national security laws for [Hong Kong]”. And the improved electoral system “safeguards the HKSAR’s governance system. Hong Kong is back on the path to progress.”
If all else fails, the reduction of directly elected seats for the district councils from 95 per cent to just 19 per cent ensures that should a few token non-patriots accidentally get nominated and win, they would have very little influence. But that is still not enough for Lee – and, by extension, Beijing – to leave it to voters to do the right thing.
They are not leaving anything to chance. In other words, there is no room for “faith” in the equation, not even in the patriots to win the patriots’ game. This is perhaps because the experience of the 2019 district council elections – when the pro-democracy and localist camps tripled their number of seats and gained clear majorities in 17 of the 18 councils at the time – is still fresh in the minds of those in power.
How much time needs to pass before those elections can be forgiven and forgotten? Would the completion of Article 23 legislation next year do the trick?
It comes down to the lack of faith in voters themselves. This then raises the question of how we can convince those in power that we can be trusted. What will it take? Do we need to pass a patriotic exam before qualifying as a voter? Or should we attend education seminars and rack up enough hours to qualify?


It would seem that it’s not just those who failed to secure nominations who need to reflect, as Lee suggested. Residents also have plenty to think about.
It’s a discombobulating thought. While many governments struggle with the lack of faith people have in them, Hong Kong people instead have to reflect on why the government has a crisis of faith in us.
Survey findings by the Hong Kong Institute of Asia-Pacific Studies at Chinese University found that trust in the Hong Kong government grew from 24.6 per cent in July 2022 to 28.2 per cent in July 2023, while distrust dropped from 28.1 per cent to 23.8 per cent. While the trust Hongkongers have in the city government is not going down, there is no telling where we stand with those in charge.
Hong Kong district council poll nominations ‘show shift towards less diversity’
The opposition is now shut out of even the district council elections and rendered irrelevant. But, for centrists who are deemed “acceptable” enough to have seats in the legislature, it boggles the mind why they are also not considered qualified to run and serve in consultative district-level bodies.
The government must look at whether the system is actually fair, just and open. It is troubling that, amid the current crisis of faith, the government still expects the people they do not trust to come out and vote.
Alice Wu is a political consultant and a former associate director of the Asia Pacific Media Network at UCLA


Exco declarations reveal new roles for ex-lawmakers as minister retains 22 flats

Hong Kong vows safe Apec meeting with plans for terror and cyberattack threats

Hong Kong needs social science to help deliver on its 5-year plan

Hong Kong, Macau student trip to Beijing shows ‘fruitful results’ of patriotic push

Hong Kong politics

Even with election safeguards, why does John Lee still not trust voters?

A pedestrian passes a large promotional poster for the 2023 district council elections, at Tsim Sha Tsui Pier on November 1. Centrists and the opposition have been all but frozen out of the upcoming election, leading to fears of reduced political diversity and representation. Photo: Jelly Tse

Has Beijing secured Hong Kong’s status as an international finance hub?

Strong rhetoric from Beijing has raised hopes that Hong Kong’s status as a financial centre will remain secure. Photo: AP

Strong rhetoric from Beijing has raised hopes that Hong Kong’s status as a financial centre will remain secure. Photo: Xinhua

Hong Kong lawmakers pass controversial bill reforming Chinese University’s governing council

The term of the current Chinese University council ended on Tuesday and an ad hoc transitional one with 13 members will be formed, according to lawmakers. Photo: K. Y. Cheng

(From left) Lawmakers Edward Lau, Tommy Cheung and Bill Tang meets the press to discuss the private bill in June. The bill will be gazetted either this Friday or the next, according to Cheung. Photo: Jelly Tse

Hong Kong’s John Lee says immigration officials should vet visa candidates for risks after scholar’s application is rejected

The city’s leader has said immigration authorities always act in accordance with procedures when reviewing visa applications. Photo: Fung Chang

Rowena He Xiaoqing, a former associate professor at Chinese University’s history department, was earlier denied a visa by immigration authorities. Photo: Handout

Hong Kong’s own national security law ‘essential’ to maintaining Beijing’s trust in city, justice secretary Paul Lam says

A flashback to protests in 2003 in Causeway Bay as marchers travel from Victoria Park in to to the Government headquarters in Central. Photo: Jonathan Wong

Paul Lam, the secretary for justice, talks about the urgent need for the city’s own national security legislation. Photo: Edmond So

Opinion

News

Hong Kong

Politics

The chief executive said during his policy address he has faith in the people, but the actions of his government tell a different story
Stripping power from district councils, cutting directly elected seats and barring the opposition from running don’t appear to be enough


John Lee said during his recent policy address that he has faith in the people of Hong Kong, but the actions of his government tell a different story. Stripping power from district councils, cutting directly elected seats and barring the opposition from running don’t appear to be enough.


Hong Kong district council election

Hong Kong national security law (NSL)

John Lee

John Lee policy address 2023

5050

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)
