appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Yue Parkinson

Until early 2022, I was content with writing in a “safe” way. My Chinese column was only critical of British politics, and my English book on China took a middle ground – which itself required some courage. Yet I decided to take a leap and speak up fully.
Most Chinese writers are only willing to politely give advice to the Chinese government, not criticise it. This is because in China, those who publicly criticise the government immediately sense that trouble is coming.
Strangely, there is no law or document outlining what Chinese people can and can’t talk about; it is up to us to guess and judge for ourselves. However, the clearest red line we have collectively drawn for ourselves is to keep silent on Chinese politics.
Article 35 of the constitution says: “Citizens of the People’s Republic of China have freedom of speech, of the press, of assembly, of association, of procession and of demonstration.”
Sadly, the Shanghai lockdown in April 2022 confirmed that all constitutional powers granted to the people can be taken away overnight, this time in the quest to achieve the government’s zero-Covid policy.
My decision to first speak out was triggered in January 2022 by the scandal of the woman found chained up in a hut in Xuzhou.
Chinese internet users flocked to social media to decry the treatment of the hitherto unknown woman of unknown origin, abducted or sold and subjected to decades of abuse, forced to give birth to eight children and kept chained up by the man who claimed to be her husband.

She was eventually rescued following the relentlessness of angry Chinese netizens. Throughout the process, it seemed the priority of the authorities was not to save her, but to prevent people from knowing the truth. I find it incredible that a country which seems so prosperous, powerful and modern to the outside world would be unwilling or unable to protect a woman’s basic rights.
While my initial public outcry was with tens of millions of other Chinese, the next time I spoke up was when I joined my Shanghai friends on WeChat to draw attention to the suffering of residents following the city’s lockdown last April.
But WeChat controls began to escalate, and popular articles or videos being circulated on the platform were often deleted so quickly that people came to the conclusion that they must contain the truth. Meanwhile, state media extolled the greatness of the zero-Covid policy and the harmony of society.
But because WeChat is indispensable to people’s daily lives – used for everything from bill payments to grocery shopping – the number of people who would risk losing their account by speaking out has decreased dramatically. The Xinjiang fire caused another brief, sharp rise in December, but calm was soon restored.


China’s sudden and complete reopening on December 7 led to a rise in the number of elderly deaths, even though many were not counted as Covid fatalities, but there was no public outcry like that seen during the Shanghai lockdown. Even when my friends lost elderly relatives who had been infected with Covid-19, they did not dare say so explicitly on WeChat.
Meanwhile, I feel fortunate, and guilty, because I live in the safety of the UK. My WeChat account serves only as a self-publishing platform, and if it is shut down, I can buy a new phone number and open another account, without my daily life being affected.
China’s reopening: the impact of Beijing’s U-turn on zero-Covid
In June 2022, the Lau China Institute at King’s College London invited me to moderate at the launch of Dr Andrew Chubb’s policy paper “Rights protection: How the UK should respond to the People’s Republic of China’s overseas influence”. While chairing the discussion, I made a public admission: “I have been living in self-censorship of speech”.
I am very happy that I am out of that cage now. Wouldn’t it be a waste to live in a free country and not exercise my right to freedom of speech? At the same time, however, I worry that my family in China may pay for my new rights in the UK.
Yue Parkinson is a freelancer writer and bilingual author of China and the West: Unravelling 100 Years of Misunderstanding, and China’s Ukraine Dilemma: The Shaping of a New World Order


Fauci refuses to answer questions at heated US Senate hearing on Covid-19 origins

What’s behind China’s recent spike in Covid-19 cases? And is it anything to worry about?

China’s provinces turn to SOE profits after worst first-quarter fiscal stress since 2020

Wang Xiaodong, derided over Covid-19 handling, comes under corruption cloud

Coronavirus China

Finding the courage to criticise Covid-19 injustice in China

The icon for WeChat, the multi-purpose social media app that is ubiquitous in mainland China. Photo: Shutterstock


A worker in a protective suit looks out from a residential area under lockdown in Shanghai in May 2022. Photo: Reuters

Why mass travel in and out of China is still months off – from ‘crazy’ flight ticket prices and Covid fears to other countries’ restrictions and visa issues

A traveller walks through Hong Kong’s Lok Ma Chau station on January 9, the first day of the Hong Kong-mainland China border reopening. Photo: Dickson Lee

A traveller arrives in the border control area at Lok Ma Chau station on the first day the border with mainland China is reopened, in Hong Kong, China, on January 9, 2023. Photo: Lam Yik / Bloomberg

A woman pours a drink for a patron at X-Cube in Taichung, Taiwan. Photo: X-Cube

Members of the media record travellers from a Xiamen Airlines flight from China arriving at Suvarnabhumi Airport in Bangkok, Thailand on January 9, 2023. Photo: AFP

As zero-Covid ends abruptly, China’s economy is living its darkest hours before the dawn

Patients lie on beds in the emergency department of a hospital amid the Covid-19 outbreak in Shanghai on January 5. Reuters

How Omicron variant of coronavirus led to bursting of China’s zero-Covid dykes

Illustration: Lau Ka-kuen

Foxconn workers confront security personnel wearing hazmat suits in Zhengzhou in November. Photo: Weibo

A worker in protective gear guards the entrance to a locked down neighbourhood in Shanghai in March last year. Photo: AFP

People hold up sheets of blank paper to criticise censorship as they march in Beijing on November 27 during a protest against the country’s strict zero-Covid measures. Photo: Getty Images/TNS

Opinion

Coronavirus

Analysis & Opinion

Amid China’s pandemic turmoil in 2022, many turned to platforms like WeChat to vent their frustration
As a Chinese living in the UK, I feel fortunate, and guilty, to have the freedom to speak out, relatively untouched by the strict censorship


Amid China’s pandemic turmoil in 2022, many turned to platforms like WeChat to vent their frustration. As a Chinese living in the UK, I feel fortunate, and guilty, to have the freedom to speak out, relatively untouched by the strict censorship.


China’s internet censorship

WeChat

China’s zero-Covid protests

Coronavirus pandemic

Coronavirus pandemic: All stories

Human rights

Human rights in China

Women and gender

5050

Expresses the views, ideas and conclusions of the author. (Eg. Enough of Crazy Rich Asians, think of crazy poor Hongkongers.)
