appConfigEntityId

bodyType

customContents

entityId

entityUuid

isVideo

articlePageQuery

article

articleSchemaContent

content

hooksArticlePageAdvertisementConfigArticle

hooksArticlePageFloatingButtonConfigArticle

appConfig

filter

json

liveArticle

Letters

Watching recent coverage of families torn apart by the mass exodus out of Hong Kong in search of “freedom”, I wondered if those who are leaving really know what kind of “freedom” they are getting themselves into.
Being from Canada, I probably take that freedom for granted. However, since I do live here, I might be willing to give up some of this freedom in exchange for some competence.
With the passing of the national security law in Hong Kong, criticising the government is pretty much impossible without consequences. Luckily for me in Canada, I’m allowed to criticise my government by voting and, luckily for me, Canada has recently announced an election.
For Hongkongers looking at Canadians with envy, let me let you in on a secret – it is not as great as you think.
I have voted for the last 20 years, and honestly there has not been one capable candidate. Every four years I get my opportunity to vote out one person and replace him or her with another just as incompetent. This is true through all levels of government.
I have voted in three mayors under whose watch the construction of a single transit line that was first proposed 15 years ago has yet to be completed. I have voted for provincial premiers who thought it was a good idea to give people up to C$14,000 (US$11,160) to buy an electric car or made it a priority that beer can’t be more C$1.
I have voted for prime ministers who think cutting taxes but not spending was the key to fiscal responsibility, and one who believes the budget will magically balance itself.
The irony is, on Western social media, one sometimes sees envy of what Hong Kong and mainland China can do despite the lack of freedoms. Yes, we might have “freedom”, but our roads are riddled with potholes. It takes us so long to complete a project, by the time it is finished, it has to be replaced again.
Our country has accumulated huge debt due to continuous fiscal mismanagement. It has become so bad that people end up giving up what Hongkongers so desperately seek by not voting at all. What’s the point?
Maybe next time when I’m behind the ballot box, I should vote for the communist dictator candidate.
A. Kwok, Toronto
Regulate, not ban, heat-not-burn products
Recently, the bills committee of the Legislative Council convened several meetings to debate the Smoking (Public Health) (Amendment) Bill 2019. The proposed legislation aims to ban the import, manufacture, distribution, sale and advertisement of alternative smoking products, including heat-not-burn products.
Heat-not-burn cigarette products and traditional cigarettes share similarities. They are both tobacco products. Hence, heat-not-burn products are considered alternative smoking products, but are different from e-cigarettes.
A heat-not-burn cigarette consists of a heating source and tobacco. The device is heated to a lower temperature than a combusted cigarette to create an aerosol that the user inhales.
In authorising the marketing of such a product in 2019, the US Food and Drug Administration imposed stringent restrictions on how it can be marketed to prevent youth access and exposure. It also noted that its scientific evaluation found that the product “contains fewer toxic chemicals than cigarette smoke, and many of the toxins identified are present at lower levels than in cigarette smoke”.
Some members of the Legislative Council have proposed regulating heated tobacco products instead of banning them outright. They argue that a total ban may drive smokers to turn to smuggled products, and result in inconvenience to tourists and businessmen who are users of alternative smoking products.
Further, taxes from the sale of heat-not-burn products could also contribute to the government’s revenue.
Law enforcement should be practical. If such products are well regulated, under-age teenagers would be denied access while adult smokers can buy them legally. The black market would be undermined, and the safety standards of accessories for heat-not-burn cigarette products, such as chargers, would be safeguarded.
Of course, at the end of the day, it is up to individual’s determination and choice to quit smoking.
K.K. Chu, Ho Man Tin
Paralympics coverage on Hong Kong TV a disgrace
I find the lack of live television coverage given to the Tokyo Paralympics a total disgrace.
The government purchased the television rights for both the Olympics and Paralympics, so that television companies could show these great events “free of charge”. The Olympics were broadcast basically 24/7, which was great.
However, there was an appalling shortage of television coverage of the Paralympics. Now TV found it appropriate to broadcast a 30-minute daily highlights show.
Once every four years, the talents of the world’s athletes with disabilities are showcased at the Paralympics. It is a travesty this year’s event was treated with such contempt by Hong Kong’s television companies.
Perhaps the government should reach out to each company and ask them to contribute to the cost of the television rights it kindly purchased.
Graeme Duncan, Jordan


South Korea steps up to plug Europe’s jet fuel deficit

Wing Shya: photographer to Wong Kar-wai on working with the great and good of Hong Kong cinema

Macron, Carney pledge closer ties in Atlantic island meeting amid strains with Trump

Trump signs bill targeting China’s Russia energy imports days before Xi’s US visit

Canada

Hongkongers moving to Canada for democracy are in for a rude shock

Friends and relatives take photos before boarding a London-bound flight at Hong Kong airport on August 8. Photo: EPA-EFE

Hong Kong star Nicholas Tse is giving up Canadian citizenship amid Chinese crackdown on entertainment industry

Nicholas Tse told CCTV that he is in the process of renouncing his Canadian citizenship. Photo: @chefnicookies

=== PHOTO CAPTURED ONLINE=== From driving luxury cars, performing on stage for his fans and cooking impressive dishes, what can't Nicholas Tse do? Photo: @??/Weibo

Zhao Wei. Photo: Wanlimu

National security law: Hong Kong authorities hit back at Next Digital, accuse it of trying to shift blame for decisions

Police arrested several senior Apple Daily executives in June. Photo: AP

People queueing up for the last edition Apple Daily in Mong Kok in the mid-night 24JUN21 SCMP / Felix Wong

Apple Daily Founder Jimmy Lai Chee-ying leave at the Lai Chi Kok Reception Centre in Lai Chi Kok before the trial. 12DEC20 SCMP / Winson Wong

What’s driving Hong Kong exodus if not the national security law?

A man hugs his mother at Hong Kong airport as he and his wife prepare to leave for Britain on July 17. Photo: Getty Images

Smoking control has helped Hongkongers live longer, new study shows, and researchers want lawmakers to stub out sales of e-cigarettes next

A group of elderly men sitting on a bench behind metal barricades that says ’No Entry', Tsim Sha Tsui. 04SEP20 SCMP / K. Y. Cheng

Hongkongers have the highest life expectancy in the world. Photo: Bloomberg

Opinion

Most read Letters to the Editor of 2021

Australia making a big mistake in taking on China  and following the US

A visitor looks at a display of Australian wines at the China International Import Expo in Shanghai on November 5. Disputes over issues ranging from Xinjaing to 5G and Australia’s support for a probe into the origin of the coronavirus have sparked a trade spat and higher Chinese  import duties or outright bans on Australian products, including wine and coal. Photo: AP

Move over zero-Covid Hong Kong, make way for ‘World City’ Singapore

People dine in the Boat Quay nightlife area in Singapore on September 24. The country has reopened its borders to vaccinated international travellers. Photo: Reuters

Why Australia will regret making an enemy of China

Protesters at a demonstration in Sydney on June 23 call on the Australian government to boycott the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics over China’s human rights record. Photo: AFP

Canadian police’s refusal of street checks holds a lesson for Hong Kong

Royal Canadian Mounted Police officers wearing masks stand outside the Senate of Canada in Ottawa, Ontario, in September 2020. Many police forces in Ontario have resisted a re-introduction of street checks to combat Covid-19. Photo: Bloomberg 

Hong Kong hotel quarantine rules: a plea for common sense and mercy

Coach registration counter at the Hong Kong International Airport, for passengers to be transported to designated quarantine hotels, on December 22. Photo: Nora Tam

UK’s  ‘green list’ for travel: why is Singapore in and Hong Kong out?

People spend time in a Hong Kong park on April 30. Diplomats in both China and Britain should lobby for Hong Kong to be included in the UK’s green list of quarantine-free travel. Photo: AP

Before leaving Hong Kong on BN(O) visa, consider Brexit and the British economy

About 300,000 Hong Kong citizens are expected to apply for a new British National (Overseas) visa route to settle in the UK, despite nearly 3 million being eligible. Photo: Bloomberg

Harsh Covid-19 rules raise risks of Hong Kong expat exodus

Hong Kong’s once-bustling nightlife district of Lan Kwai Fong wears a deserted look, in Central on June 14. Photo: Edmond So

Mark of the beast? Amid Covid-19 suffering, there are worthier Bible lessons to heed

Anti-vaccination protesters take part in a rally against Covid-19 vaccine mandates in Santa Monica, California, on August 29. Photo: AFP


Readers discuss the poor choice of candidates in Canadian elections, a proposed law to ban alternative smoking products, the rise in myopia among children amid the pandemic, and television coverage of the Paralympics



Readers discuss the poor choice of candidates in Canadian elections, a proposed law to ban alternative smoking products, the rise in myopia among children amid the pandemic, and television coverage of the Paralympics.
